
New York Marriott Marquis
Best for busy, central Times Square access, large meetings and families.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
New York Marriott Marquis is a large, modern 50-story hotel in Times Square that suits theatergoers, groups, and event planners. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel is a storied Upper East Side five-star hotel with classic luxury and celebrity history — read this if you want a Times Square hub vs. a quieter, Old‑World New York stay.
Updated · about 3.2 km apart

Best for busy, central Times Square access, large meetings and families.

Best for quieter luxury, proximity to Central Park and a classic New York hotel experience.
When New York Marriott Marquis wins: choose the Marriott Marquis if you want to be in the middle of Times Square, need lots of meeting or ballroom space, want multiple on-site restaurants including The View (the city’s only revolving restaurant), or are traveling with family and want a big, activity-filled hotel.
When The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel wins: choose The Carlyle if you prefer a refined Upper East Side address near Central Park, a smaller, quieter property with a full-service spa and famous bars/restaurants (Bemelman's Bar), and historic, classic New York style.
Bottom line: pick the Marriott Marquis for scale, location and event capacity; pick The Carlyle for old‑school luxury, a more intimate stay and Central Park access.
| Category | New York Marriott Marquis | The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Large, modern, busy Times Square hotel with event focus | Storied Upper East Side luxury hotel with classic, quieter atmosphere |
| Location | 1535 Broadway — in the heart of Times Square/Theater District | 35 E 76th St — a short walk to Central Park and Museum Mile |
| Size | Roughly 1,900+ rooms and large-scale event space | 188 guestrooms |
| Age / architecture | 50-story tower built 1985 with large atrium, renovated 2022 | Historic luxury hotel (Art Deco references); building age not published in supplier listing |
| Pools | No on-site pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Four on-site venues including The View (revolving rooftop), Revel & Rye and Broadway Lounge | Two restaurants, Bemelman's Bar and a lounge; 24-hour room service |
| Spa / wellness | Marquis Fitness Center (4,000 sq ft), 24/7; no confirmed on-site spa | Full-service spa (listed in supplier amenities) and fitness facilities |
| Known for | Times Square location, large ballrooms and event capacity | Celebrity history, classic New York reputation, proximity to Central Park |
| Accessibility & transport | Steps from Broadway theaters and major subway hubs (Times Sq‑42 St), many subway lines | Upper East Side location with nearby subway options; preferred airport listed as LGA |
| Pet policy | Pets not allowed (service animals excepted) | Pet fee policy listed (USD 50 per pet, per night) — pets allowed with fee |
New York Marriott Marquis places you on Times Square — ideal for Broadway, nightlife and short walks to Rockefeller Center.
Pick the Marriott for maximum proximity to Broadway and Times Square energy.
The Carlyle sits on the Upper East Side, a short walk from Central Park and the Met.
Choose The Carlyle for a calmer, museum-and-park–focused location.
Marriott Marquis has a very large room inventory with many room types to suit families and groups.
Marriott works for travelers who need many room-type options or family connectivity.
The Carlyle has 188 guestrooms with classic luxury touches and multiple suite options.
The Carlyle is better if you want a smaller hotel with a selection of suites and traditional luxury amenities.
Marriott Marquis offers several dining options suited to a range of tastes and show-night plans.
If you want theatrical dining and skyline views, the Marriott has more high-energy F&B options.
The Carlyle emphasizes classic New York dining and famous bars.
The Carlyle suits travelers seeking refined, classic hotel dining and historic bar atmospheres.
Marriott Marquis emphasizes fitness and huge event spaces rather than pool or spa facilities.
This is a hotel for events, meetings and a strong fitness offering — not for poolside leisure.
The Carlyle highlights a full-service spa and personalized services.
The Carlyle is the pick if an on-site spa and tailored service matter more than large event space.
Marriott Marquis pairs a 24/7 fitness center with an energetic nightlife and easy Broadway access.
Choose Marriott if you want round‑the‑clock fitness and Times Square nightlife at your doorstep.
The Carlyle provides quieter evenings with classic hotel bars and neighborhood nightlife.
The Carlyle suits guests who prefer subdued, classic New York evenings over bright Times Square activity.

New York Marriott Marquis — steps from theaters and Times Square, with a Broadway theater integrated into the building.

The Carlyle — storied history, Upper East Side address and a classic hotel bar scene (Bemelman's Bar).

New York Marriott Marquis — over 100,000 sq ft of event space and very large ballrooms for big celebrations.

The Carlyle — full-service spa, bespoke concierge and a smaller, more intimate property.
The Carlyle is closer (about 0.4 km from Central Park); the Marriott Marquis is roughly a 15-minute walk north of the park.
New York Marriott Marquis — it sits in the Theater District with a Broadway theater in the building and immediate access to show venues.
The Carlyle lists a full-service spa in its supplier amenities; the Marriott Marquis does not have a confirmed on-site spa and has no pool.
New York Marriott Marquis — it has vastly more meeting and ballroom space and is set up for large-scale events.
Explore how New York Marriott Marquis stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·